Siena Vs Tuft & Needle Mattress Comparison Guide 2024

{"compair_title":"Siena vs Tuft & Needle Mattress  (2024)<\/br>\nWhat you need to know","compair_content":"Tuft & Needle charge twice the money for fewer layers, and way less trial. But what about Siena? With more comfort layers, more time to test it out, and at almost half the price, Siena offers you a top quality mattress at a wallet friendly price. More Zzzs for less money - there's no competition!","top_logo":{"url":"https:\/\/www.sienasleep.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2021\/12\/Vector.png","id":223,"size":""},"bottom_logo":"Tuft & Needle","bottom_logo_typography_typography":"custom","bottom_logo_typography_font_family":"Centra","bottom_logo_typography_font_size":{"unit":"px","size":"40","sizes":[]},"bottom_logo_typography_font_size_mobile":{"unit":"px","size":"30","sizes":[]},"bottom_logo_typography_font_weight":"700","bottom_logo_typography_text_transform":"capitalize","bottom_logo_typography_line_height":{"unit":"px","size":"60","sizes":[]},"bottom_logo_typography_line_height_mobile":{"unit":"px","size":"45","sizes":[]},"compair_title_typography_typography":"custom","compair_title_typography_font_family":"Centra","compair_title_typography_font_size":{"unit":"px","size":64,"sizes":[]},"compair_title_typography_font_size_mobile":{"unit":"px","size":"30","sizes":[]},"compair_title_typography_font_weight":"400","compair_title_typography_text_transform":"capitalize","compair_title_typography_line_height":{"unit":"px","size":68,"sizes":[]},"compair_title_typography_line_height_mobile":{"unit":"px","size":"45","sizes":[]},"compair_title_color":"#143232","compair_content_color":"#001E1E","gradient_color_b":"#EDEBE9","__globals__":{"gradient_color_a":"","gradient_color_b":"","compair_title_typography_typography":"globals\/typography?id=primary","compair_title_color":"","compair_content_typography_typography":"","compair_content_color":"","bottom_logo_color":"","bottom_logo_typography_typography":"globals\/typography?id=7c3b5d8"},"compair_content_typography_typography":"custom","compair_content_typography_font_family":"Centra","compair_content_typography_font_size":{"unit":"px","size":"20","sizes":[]},"compair_content_typography_font_size_mobile":{"unit":"px","size":"18","sizes":[]},"compair_content_typography_font_weight":"normal","compair_content_typography_text_transform":"none","compair_content_typography_font_style":"normal","compair_content_typography_text_decoration":"none","compair_content_typography_line_height":{"unit":"px","size":"30","sizes":[]},"compair_content_typography_line_height_mobile":{"unit":"px","size":"27","sizes":[]},"gradient_color_a":"#87A5A0","custom_css":"selector .gwm_compair_hero__promoTitle,\nselector .gwm_compair_hero__offerEnds,\nselector .gwm_compair_hero__saleEndsText {\n    display: none;\n}\n\nselector .gwm_compair_hero__title {\n    max-width: 754px;\n    margin-top: 16px !important;\n}\n\nselector .gwm_compair_hero__body {\n    max-width: 816px;\n}","bottom_logo_color":"#2B2823","bottom_logo_typography_font_style":"normal","bottom_logo_typography_text_decoration":"none","bottom_logo_typography_letter_spacing":{"unit":"px","size":"","sizes":[]},"bottom_logo_typography_word_spacing":{"unit":"px","size":"","sizes":[]},"compair_title_typography_font_style":"","compair_title_typography_text_decoration":"","compair_title_typography_letter_spacing":{"unit":"px","size":"","sizes":[]},"compair_title_typography_word_spacing":{"unit":"px","size":"","sizes":[]},"compair_content_typography_letter_spacing":{"unit":"px","size":"","sizes":[]},"compair_content_typography_word_spacing":{"unit":"px","size":"","sizes":[]},"_title":"","_margin":{"unit":"px","top":"","right":"","bottom":"","left":"","isLinked":true},"_padding":{"unit":"px","top":"","right":"","bottom":"","left":"","isLinked":true},"_element_width":"","_element_width_tablet":"","_element_width_mobile":"","_element_custom_width":null,"_element_vertical_align":null,"_position":"","_offset_orientation_h":null,"_offset_x":null,"_offset_x_end":null,"_offset_orientation_v":null,"_offset_y":null,"_offset_y_end":null,"_z_index":"","_element_id":"","_css_classes":"","e_display_conditions":"","motion_fx_motion_fx_scrolling":"","motion_fx_translateY_effect":null,"motion_fx_translateY_direction":null,"motion_fx_translateY_speed":null,"motion_fx_translateY_affectedRange":null,"motion_fx_translateX_effect":null,"motion_fx_translateX_direction":null,"motion_fx_translateX_speed":null,"motion_fx_translateX_affectedRange":null,"motion_fx_opacity_effect":null,"motion_fx_opacity_direction":null,"motion_fx_opacity_level":null,"motion_fx_opacity_range":null,"motion_fx_blur_effect":null,"motion_fx_blur_direction":null,"motion_fx_blur_level":null,"motion_fx_blur_range":null,"motion_fx_rotateZ_effect":null,"motion_fx_rotateZ_direction":null,"motion_fx_rotateZ_speed":null,"motion_fx_rotateZ_affectedRange":null,"motion_fx_scale_effect":null,"motion_fx_scale_direction":null,"motion_fx_scale_speed":null,"motion_fx_scale_range":null,"motion_fx_transform_origin_x":null,"motion_fx_transform_origin_y":null,"motion_fx_devices":null,"motion_fx_range":null,"motion_fx_motion_fx_mouse":"","motion_fx_mouseTrack_effect":null,"motion_fx_mouseTrack_direction":null,"motion_fx_mouseTrack_speed":null,"motion_fx_tilt_effect":null,"motion_fx_tilt_direction":null,"motion_fx_tilt_speed":null,"sticky":"","sticky_on":null,"sticky_offset":null,"sticky_offset_tablet":null,"sticky_offset_mobile":null,"sticky_effects_offset":null,"sticky_effects_offset_tablet":null,"sticky_effects_offset_mobile":null,"sticky_parent":null,"_animation":"","_animation_tablet":"","_animation_mobile":"","animation_duration":null,"_animation_delay":null,"_transform_rotate_popover":"","_transform_rotateZ_effect":null,"_transform_rotateZ_effect_tablet":null,"_transform_rotateZ_effect_mobile":null,"_transform_rotate_3d":null,"_transform_rotateX_effect":null,"_transform_rotateX_effect_tablet":null,"_transform_rotateX_effect_mobile":null,"_transform_rotateY_effect":null,"_transform_rotateY_effect_tablet":null,"_transform_rotateY_effect_mobile":null,"_transform_perspective_effect":null,"_transform_perspective_effect_tablet":null,"_transform_perspective_effect_mobile":null,"_transform_translate_popover":"","_transform_translateX_effect":null,"_transform_translateX_effect_tablet":null,"_transform_translateX_effect_mobile":null,"_transform_translateY_effect":null,"_transform_translateY_effect_tablet":null,"_transform_translateY_effect_mobile":null,"_transform_scale_popover":"","_transform_keep_proportions":"yes","_transform_scale_effect":null,"_transform_scale_effect_tablet":null,"_transform_scale_effect_mobile":null,"_transform_scaleX_effect":null,"_transform_scaleX_effect_tablet":null,"_transform_scaleX_effect_mobile":null,"_transform_scaleY_effect":null,"_transform_scaleY_effect_tablet":null,"_transform_scaleY_effect_mobile":null,"_transform_skew_popover":"","_transform_skewX_effect":null,"_transform_skewX_effect_tablet":null,"_transform_skewX_effect_mobile":null,"_transform_skewY_effect":null,"_transform_skewY_effect_tablet":null,"_transform_skewY_effect_mobile":null,"_transform_flipX_effect":"","_transform_flipY_effect":"","_transform_rotate_popover_hover":"","_transform_rotateZ_effect_hover":null,"_transform_rotateZ_effect_hover_tablet":null,"_transform_rotateZ_effect_hover_mobile":null,"_transform_rotate_3d_hover":null,"_transform_rotateX_effect_hover":null,"_transform_rotateX_effect_hover_tablet":null,"_transform_rotateX_effect_hover_mobile":null,"_transform_rotateY_effect_hover":null,"_transform_rotateY_effect_hover_tablet":null,"_transform_rotateY_effect_hover_mobile":null,"_transform_perspective_effect_hover":null,"_transform_perspective_effect_hover_tablet":null,"_transform_perspective_effect_hover_mobile":null,"_transform_translate_popover_hover":"","_transform_translateX_effect_hover":null,"_transform_translateX_effect_hover_tablet":null,"_transform_translateX_effect_hover_mobile":null,"_transform_translateY_effect_hover":null,"_transform_translateY_effect_hover_tablet":null,"_transform_translateY_effect_hover_mobile":null,"_transform_scale_popover_hover":"","_transform_keep_proportions_hover":"yes","_transform_scale_effect_hover":null,"_transform_scale_effect_hover_tablet":null,"_transform_scale_effect_hover_mobile":null,"_transform_scaleX_effect_hover":null,"_transform_scaleX_effect_hover_tablet":null,"_transform_scaleX_effect_hover_mobile":null,"_transform_scaleY_effect_hover":null,"_transform_scaleY_effect_hover_tablet":null,"_transform_scaleY_effect_hover_mobile":null,"_transform_skew_popover_hover":"","_transform_skewX_effect_hover":null,"_transform_skewX_effect_hover_tablet":null,"_transform_skewX_effect_hover_mobile":null,"_transform_skewY_effect_hover":null,"_transform_skewY_effect_hover_tablet":null,"_transform_skewY_effect_hover_mobile":null,"_transform_flipX_effect_hover":"","_transform_flipY_effect_hover":"","_transform_transition_hover":{"unit":"px","size":"","sizes":[]},"motion_fx_transform_x_anchor_point":null,"motion_fx_transform_y_anchor_point":null,"_background_background":"","_background_color":null,"_background_color_stop":null,"_background_color_b":null,"_background_color_b_stop":null,"_background_gradient_type":null,"_background_gradient_angle":null,"_background_gradient_position":null,"_background_image":null,"_background_image_tablet":null,"_background_image_mobile":null,"_background_position":null,"_background_xpos":null,"_background_ypos":null,"_background_attachment":null,"_background_repeat":null,"_background_size":null,"_background_bg_width":null,"_background_video_link":null,"_background_video_start":null,"_background_video_end":null,"_background_play_once":null,"_background_play_on_mobile":null,"_background_privacy_mode":null,"_background_video_fallback":null,"_background_slideshow_gallery":null,"_background_slideshow_loop":null,"_background_slideshow_slide_duration":null,"_background_slideshow_slide_transition":null,"_background_slideshow_transition_duration":null,"_background_slideshow_background_size":null,"_background_slideshow_background_position":null,"_background_slideshow_lazyload":null,"_background_slideshow_ken_burns":null,"_background_slideshow_ken_burns_zoom_direction":null,"_background_hover_background":"","_background_hover_color":null,"_background_hover_color_stop":null,"_background_hover_color_b":null,"_background_hover_color_b_stop":null,"_background_hover_gradient_type":null,"_background_hover_gradient_angle":null,"_background_hover_gradient_position":null,"_background_hover_image":null,"_background_hover_image_tablet":null,"_background_hover_image_mobile":null,"_background_hover_position":null,"_background_hover_xpos":null,"_background_hover_ypos":null,"_background_hover_attachment":null,"_background_hover_repeat":null,"_background_hover_size":null,"_background_hover_bg_width":null,"_background_hover_video_link":null,"_background_hover_video_start":null,"_background_hover_video_end":null,"_background_hover_play_once":null,"_background_hover_play_on_mobile":null,"_background_hover_privacy_mode":null,"_background_hover_video_fallback":null,"_background_hover_slideshow_gallery":null,"_background_hover_slideshow_loop":null,"_background_hover_slideshow_slide_duration":null,"_background_hover_slideshow_slide_transition":null,"_background_hover_slideshow_transition_duration":null,"_background_hover_slideshow_background_size":null,"_background_hover_slideshow_background_position":null,"_background_hover_slideshow_lazyload":null,"_background_hover_slideshow_ken_burns":null,"_background_hover_slideshow_ken_burns_zoom_direction":null,"_background_hover_transition":{"unit":"px","size":"","sizes":[]},"_border_border":"","_border_width":null,"_border_color":null,"_border_radius":{"unit":"px","top":"","right":"","bottom":"","left":"","isLinked":true},"_box_shadow_box_shadow_type":"","_box_shadow_box_shadow":null,"_box_shadow_box_shadow_position":null,"_border_hover_border":"","_border_hover_width":null,"_border_hover_color":null,"_border_radius_hover":{"unit":"px","top":"","right":"","bottom":"","left":"","isLinked":true},"_box_shadow_hover_box_shadow_type":"","_box_shadow_hover_box_shadow":null,"_box_shadow_hover_box_shadow_position":null,"_border_hover_transition":{"unit":"px","size":"","sizes":[]},"_mask_switch":"","_mask_shape":null,"_mask_image":null,"_mask_notice":null,"_mask_size":null,"_mask_size_scale":null,"_mask_position":null,"_mask_position_x":null,"_mask_position_y":null,"_mask_repeat":null,"hide_desktop":"","hide_tablet":"","hide_mobile":"","_attributes":"","nectar":false,"dreamcloud":false}

What makes Siena the grand champion of comfort?

Siena’s focus has been on engineering a perfect night’s sleep.

Price (Queen)

Materials

Warranty

Trial

Free Returns

Free shipping

Firmness

Height

Siena

5-layer construction

10 years

180 nights

6.5

10”

Shop Now

Get financing

Tuft & Needle

$761*

2 layers of memory foam

10 years

100 nights

✔️

10"

*Pricing as of 04/09/2024. See Terms.

*Mattress model used for comparison is the Essential T&N Original Mattress. For full details please see Details Page.

Siena - “Hands down the best sleep”

“Boy is it hard to choose a mattress. I’ve slept on a Tuft and Needle, a Casper and a Zinus and my new Siena is hands down the best sleep of the lot. I guess I got lucky with my choice.”

T&N - “We are so disappointed”

“We bought this mattress 3 years ago and were really happy with it from the get go. Fast forward to now and the mattress is completely and utterly shot. It offers zero support, it tips us off the side of the bed, it’s a nightmare. My husband and I are not large people, and this mattress has not held up at all. We are so disappointed, we wake up after a terrible night's sleep in pain. It’s just a huge shame.”

Certifications Are Nice: But They Come At A Price

Best Memory Foam Mattress 2024

FORBES

Best Cheap Memory Foam Mattress 2024

SLEEP FOUNDATION

Best Mattress Under $500 2024

SLEEP FOUNDATION

Best Mattress for Airbnb and Vacation Rental Properties 2024

SLEEP FOUNDATION

Best Affordable Mattress 2024

SLUMBER SEARCH

Best Overall 2024

USA Today

*Siena has certain affiliate advertising relationships with the above publications. Siena has no editorial influence over such reviews or awards.

The problem with Tuft & Needle

More money… Less Mattress?

That doesn’t sound like a good deal to us! Tuft and Needle’s lowest price model (the very basic looking Original) is almost twice the price of the Siena. For no clear reason, they’re asking you for almost $400 more. Kinda feels like burning money to us. So the question is…

What’s the extra money for?

To be honest, we’re simply not sure. And that’s the worry with any purchase, right? Are you paying more than you should? With the Tuft & Needle Original, you’re paying a WAY more than for a Siena, and you’re getting fewer layers to boot. We’d rather you kept that extra cash, got just as awesome (if not better) a sleep, and did something fun with it (or just, ya know, save it for a rainy day).

Fewer layers. Less support?

A Tuft & Needle Original only has two basic layers of foam. We know a thing or two about mattresses, but we can’t explain how fewer layers ends up costing you more. Plus, some expert reviewers have concluded that this simple structure is not very supportive for heavier folks. Siena’s three layers are designed to provide comfort and support for all body shapes.

Almost half the time to decide

Tuft & Needle give you just 100 nights to decide if it's right for you. As anyone who watches the years fly past at an alarming rate, 100 nights can feel so short when you’re getting used to something new. Siena’s home trial is almost twice as long. Giving you more time to settle into your new mattress. With Siena, you don’t have to rush to decide.

The Siena Mattress

Soft, Durable Cover

Our cover is soft to the touch and breathable to keep you cool and comfortable.

Responsive Gel Memory Foam

This 2” layer of pressure relieving gel-infused memory foam adapts to your unique body shape and size, while contouring to your curves.

Support Foam

Four inches of convoluted foam further cushions your body, giving you just the right level of comfort and support. Ripples in the foam allow for enhanced airflow.

Foundational Foam

This sturdy 4” stability foam layer is strong, durable, and allows the comfort and support layers above to work their magic.

Shift-Resistant Lower Cover

The durable lower cover keeps all of the mattress layers perfectly in place and prevents shifting.

Tuft & Needle Original Mattress

White cover

White breathable cover.

Tuft &Needle Adaptive® foam

An attempt to make normal memory foam sound more fancy? Probably

Base Layer

Base support layer with tougher polyfoam.

It’s time to sleep on a Siena…

“This Is Quite Simply A Stunning Mattress At An Impressively Low Price.”

Not our words. That’s the conclusion of “Slumber Search” after a rigorous test of the Siena mattress. You see, instead of trying to take more of your money, we focus on giving you a great night’s sleep at a fair price. The experts and everyday folk agree, the Siena is one seriously comfy mattress.

Top mattress. Low price.

Instead of wasting money trying to reinvent the wheel. Or come up with marketing gimmicks to get you to spend more money. We focus all our time on the things that really matter. That is, designing a really comfortable mattress that correctly supports your body. Manufacturing it to really high standards. Making sure the ordering and delivery process is smooth. And keeping the cost as low as possible for you.

Great sleep. Made easier.

Getting a new mattress shouldn’t be hard work. It should be easy to buy, test and return a mattress. And it should be risk-free and stress-free for you. That’s why you get a generous 180-night home trial, so you have time to really test it out. That’s why you get free shipping and returns, because you shouldn’t have to pay while you make that decision. And it’s why you get a 10-year warranty, without the annoying small print.

Real service. Not just a smile.

Good customer service doesn’t happen by accident. That’s why we work hard to give you a great experience. But we also know a happy person on the phone doesn’t make up for problems with your order. So we invest in technology, logistics and people to make sure everything runs smoothly. Because while a smile is nice, we know a great product delivered on time is a better way to make you happy